Friday, August 29, 2025
  • Login
Gamera
  • Home
  • Gaming News
    Old Country Update Introduces Open World Mode

    Old Country Update Introduces Open World Mode

    Steam Faces Ongoing Impact from Visa and Mastercard’s Censorship

    Steam Faces Ongoing Impact from Visa and Mastercard’s Censorship

    inZOI Arrives on PS5 Next Year: New Opportunities for Console Gamers

    inZOI Arrives on PS5 Next Year: New Opportunities for Console Gamers

    The End of AOL Dial-Up: A Reminder That All Empires Eventually Fall

    The End of AOL Dial-Up: A Reminder That All Empires Eventually Fall

    Excitement Builds in Love and Deepspace: Tomorrow’s New Banner Unveils Summer Vacation Memories for All Five Husbandos

    Excitement Builds in Love and Deepspace: Tomorrow’s New Banner Unveils Summer Vacation Memories for All Five Husbandos

    We’re Probably Getting a Revolutionary Video Game

    We’re Probably Getting a Revolutionary Video Game

  • PlayStation
    [Review] Lost Twins 2 on PlayStation 5

    [Review] Lost Twins 2 on PlayStation 5

    Bestselling PS5 Game of 2025 Now Available on PS Store

    Bestselling PS5 Game of 2025 Now Available on PS Store

    PlayStation Blog Highlights: Mortal Kombat 1, Marvel’s Spider-Man, Sword of the Sea, Earth Defense Force 6, and More

    PlayStation Blog Highlights: Mortal Kombat 1, Marvel’s Spider-Man, Sword of the Sea, Earth Defense Force 6, and More

    Diablo 4 Season 9 Mythic: Not Suited for Everyone

    Diablo 4 Season 9 Mythic: Not Suited for Everyone

    Slot-Style Gaming and Bite-Sized Adventures: How PS Plus Transforms Our Gaming Experience

    Slot-Style Gaming and Bite-Sized Adventures: How PS Plus Transforms Our Gaming Experience

    [Title Rewrite] Winners Announced for IREM Collection Volume 3 (PlayStation) Free Games Giveaway

    [Title Rewrite] Winners Announced for IREM Collection Volume 3 (PlayStation) Free Games Giveaway

  • Xbox
    Call of Duty’s Latest Announcement: A Full Circle Moment That Leaves Me Unsure

    Call of Duty’s Latest Announcement: A Full Circle Moment That Leaves Me Unsure

    Helldivers 2: Recap the Story Before the August 26 Launch

    Helldivers 2: Recap the Story Before the August 26 Launch

    I’m Pre-Ordering Battlefield 6—Try and Stop Me

    I’m Pre-Ordering Battlefield 6—Try and Stop Me

    Ra Ra Boom: Punch-Worthy Villains Await

    Ra Ra Boom: Punch-Worthy Villains Await

    What GTA and Red Dead Redemption Can Learn from Mafia: Embracing the Old Country

    What GTA and Red Dead Redemption Can Learn from Mafia: Embracing the Old Country

    Survey Suggests Potential New Features for Future Sims 4 Updates

    Survey Suggests Potential New Features for Future Sims 4 Updates

  • Nintendo
    Z-A Announces Beneficial Quality of Life Update

    Z-A Announces Beneficial Quality of Life Update

    Nintendo eShop Update: August 14, 2025 (North America)

    Nintendo eShop Update: August 14, 2025 (North America)

    Final Fantasy 10 Fans Showcase Their Yuna and Tidus Cosplay

    Final Fantasy 10 Fans Showcase Their Yuna and Tidus Cosplay

    Class of Heroes 3 Remaster Launches on Nintendo Switch This September

    Class of Heroes 3 Remaster Launches on Nintendo Switch This September

    Review of Heretic and Hexen

    Review of Heretic and Hexen

    Player Discovers Atlas in an Incredible Location in No Man’s Sky

    Player Discovers Atlas in an Incredible Location in No Man’s Sky

  • PC Gaming
    Cult-Classic RPG “Off” Arrives on Steam After 17-Year Wait

    Cult-Classic RPG “Off” Arrives on Steam After 17-Year Wait

    What’s Coming in the Diablo 4 PTR Update 2.4.0?

    What’s Coming in the Diablo 4 PTR Update 2.4.0?

    Smoke grenades dominate the Battlefield 6 beta meta

    Smoke grenades dominate the Battlefield 6 beta meta

    Hellblade 2 Debuts on PS5 with Upgraded Features: Is the Excitement Justified?

    Hellblade 2 Debuts on PS5 with Upgraded Features: Is the Excitement Justified?

    Sega’s Gaming Division Sees 13% Sales Decline

    Sega’s Gaming Division Sees 13% Sales Decline

    Snag the Complete Batman Arkham Series Plus 12 More Games for Just

    Snag the Complete Batman Arkham Series Plus 12 More Games for Just $12

  • Virtual Reality
    Celebrating 9 Years of The Ghost Howls!

    Celebrating 9 Years of The Ghost Howls!

    Empire City Reveals Initial Parkour Gameplay on Quest 3

    Empire City Reveals Initial Parkour Gameplay on Quest 3

    ‘Forefront’ Launches Open Alpha: Experience Battlefield-Style VR Shooter with 16 vs. 16 Multiplayer Action

    ‘Forefront’ Launches Open Alpha: Experience Battlefield-Style VR Shooter with 16 vs. 16 Multiplayer Action

    VR Support for ‘Lushfoil Photography Sim’ Announced for Upcoming Release

    VR Support for ‘Lushfoil Photography Sim’ Announced for Upcoming Release

    Top-Rated Single-Player VR Game of 2025 Arrives on Quest 3 This November

    Top-Rated Single-Player VR Game of 2025 Arrives on Quest 3 This November

    Operator XR Lands .7M VR Training Deal with Texas Department of Public Safety

    Operator XR Lands $3.7M VR Training Deal with Texas Department of Public Safety

  • Consoles
    Modder Creates Gaming Handheld Featuring RTX 4090 Laptop GPU and Intel i9-14900HX with 12.5-Inch 4K Display and 175W Mobile GPU

    Modder Creates Gaming Handheld Featuring RTX 4090 Laptop GPU and Intel i9-14900HX with 12.5-Inch 4K Display and 175W Mobile GPU

    Self-Taught Modder Creates Fully Transparent Game Boy Color Circuit Board with Stunning Design in Clear Shell

    Self-Taught Modder Creates Fully Transparent Game Boy Color Circuit Board with Stunning Design in Clear Shell

    Hardware Enthusiast Attempts to Run NVMe SSD on Switch 2; Adapter Issues Persist, but Future Possibilities with microSD Express Emulation Remain

    Hardware Enthusiast Attempts to Run NVMe SSD on Switch 2; Adapter Issues Persist, but Future Possibilities with microSD Express Emulation Remain

    U.S. Crackdown Captures Duo Behind Covert GPU Supply to China’s AI Industry

    U.S. Crackdown Captures Duo Behind Covert GPU Supply to China’s AI Industry

    AMD’s Z2 Extreme Surpasses Intel’s Lunar Lake in New Gaming Benchmarks—MSI Claw 8 at 17W Shows Z2E Leading by 8.5%, Slips to 6% at 30W

    AMD’s Z2 Extreme Surpasses Intel’s Lunar Lake in New Gaming Benchmarks—MSI Claw 8 at 17W Shows Z2E Leading by 8.5%, Slips to 6% at 30W

    Nintendo Switch 2 Requires Air Conditioning in Hot Climates: Avoid Playing Above 35°C (95°F) to Prevent Overheating

    Nintendo Switch 2 Requires Air Conditioning in Hot Climates: Avoid Playing Above 35°C (95°F) to Prevent Overheating

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Gaming News
    Old Country Update Introduces Open World Mode

    Old Country Update Introduces Open World Mode

    Steam Faces Ongoing Impact from Visa and Mastercard’s Censorship

    Steam Faces Ongoing Impact from Visa and Mastercard’s Censorship

    inZOI Arrives on PS5 Next Year: New Opportunities for Console Gamers

    inZOI Arrives on PS5 Next Year: New Opportunities for Console Gamers

    The End of AOL Dial-Up: A Reminder That All Empires Eventually Fall

    The End of AOL Dial-Up: A Reminder That All Empires Eventually Fall

    Excitement Builds in Love and Deepspace: Tomorrow’s New Banner Unveils Summer Vacation Memories for All Five Husbandos

    Excitement Builds in Love and Deepspace: Tomorrow’s New Banner Unveils Summer Vacation Memories for All Five Husbandos

    We’re Probably Getting a Revolutionary Video Game

    We’re Probably Getting a Revolutionary Video Game

  • PlayStation
    [Review] Lost Twins 2 on PlayStation 5

    [Review] Lost Twins 2 on PlayStation 5

    Bestselling PS5 Game of 2025 Now Available on PS Store

    Bestselling PS5 Game of 2025 Now Available on PS Store

    PlayStation Blog Highlights: Mortal Kombat 1, Marvel’s Spider-Man, Sword of the Sea, Earth Defense Force 6, and More

    PlayStation Blog Highlights: Mortal Kombat 1, Marvel’s Spider-Man, Sword of the Sea, Earth Defense Force 6, and More

    Diablo 4 Season 9 Mythic: Not Suited for Everyone

    Diablo 4 Season 9 Mythic: Not Suited for Everyone

    Slot-Style Gaming and Bite-Sized Adventures: How PS Plus Transforms Our Gaming Experience

    Slot-Style Gaming and Bite-Sized Adventures: How PS Plus Transforms Our Gaming Experience

    [Title Rewrite] Winners Announced for IREM Collection Volume 3 (PlayStation) Free Games Giveaway

    [Title Rewrite] Winners Announced for IREM Collection Volume 3 (PlayStation) Free Games Giveaway

  • Xbox
    Call of Duty’s Latest Announcement: A Full Circle Moment That Leaves Me Unsure

    Call of Duty’s Latest Announcement: A Full Circle Moment That Leaves Me Unsure

    Helldivers 2: Recap the Story Before the August 26 Launch

    Helldivers 2: Recap the Story Before the August 26 Launch

    I’m Pre-Ordering Battlefield 6—Try and Stop Me

    I’m Pre-Ordering Battlefield 6—Try and Stop Me

    Ra Ra Boom: Punch-Worthy Villains Await

    Ra Ra Boom: Punch-Worthy Villains Await

    What GTA and Red Dead Redemption Can Learn from Mafia: Embracing the Old Country

    What GTA and Red Dead Redemption Can Learn from Mafia: Embracing the Old Country

    Survey Suggests Potential New Features for Future Sims 4 Updates

    Survey Suggests Potential New Features for Future Sims 4 Updates

  • Nintendo
    Z-A Announces Beneficial Quality of Life Update

    Z-A Announces Beneficial Quality of Life Update

    Nintendo eShop Update: August 14, 2025 (North America)

    Nintendo eShop Update: August 14, 2025 (North America)

    Final Fantasy 10 Fans Showcase Their Yuna and Tidus Cosplay

    Final Fantasy 10 Fans Showcase Their Yuna and Tidus Cosplay

    Class of Heroes 3 Remaster Launches on Nintendo Switch This September

    Class of Heroes 3 Remaster Launches on Nintendo Switch This September

    Review of Heretic and Hexen

    Review of Heretic and Hexen

    Player Discovers Atlas in an Incredible Location in No Man’s Sky

    Player Discovers Atlas in an Incredible Location in No Man’s Sky

  • PC Gaming
    Cult-Classic RPG “Off” Arrives on Steam After 17-Year Wait

    Cult-Classic RPG “Off” Arrives on Steam After 17-Year Wait

    What’s Coming in the Diablo 4 PTR Update 2.4.0?

    What’s Coming in the Diablo 4 PTR Update 2.4.0?

    Smoke grenades dominate the Battlefield 6 beta meta

    Smoke grenades dominate the Battlefield 6 beta meta

    Hellblade 2 Debuts on PS5 with Upgraded Features: Is the Excitement Justified?

    Hellblade 2 Debuts on PS5 with Upgraded Features: Is the Excitement Justified?

    Sega’s Gaming Division Sees 13% Sales Decline

    Sega’s Gaming Division Sees 13% Sales Decline

    Snag the Complete Batman Arkham Series Plus 12 More Games for Just

    Snag the Complete Batman Arkham Series Plus 12 More Games for Just $12

  • Virtual Reality
    Celebrating 9 Years of The Ghost Howls!

    Celebrating 9 Years of The Ghost Howls!

    Empire City Reveals Initial Parkour Gameplay on Quest 3

    Empire City Reveals Initial Parkour Gameplay on Quest 3

    ‘Forefront’ Launches Open Alpha: Experience Battlefield-Style VR Shooter with 16 vs. 16 Multiplayer Action

    ‘Forefront’ Launches Open Alpha: Experience Battlefield-Style VR Shooter with 16 vs. 16 Multiplayer Action

    VR Support for ‘Lushfoil Photography Sim’ Announced for Upcoming Release

    VR Support for ‘Lushfoil Photography Sim’ Announced for Upcoming Release

    Top-Rated Single-Player VR Game of 2025 Arrives on Quest 3 This November

    Top-Rated Single-Player VR Game of 2025 Arrives on Quest 3 This November

    Operator XR Lands .7M VR Training Deal with Texas Department of Public Safety

    Operator XR Lands $3.7M VR Training Deal with Texas Department of Public Safety

  • Consoles
    Modder Creates Gaming Handheld Featuring RTX 4090 Laptop GPU and Intel i9-14900HX with 12.5-Inch 4K Display and 175W Mobile GPU

    Modder Creates Gaming Handheld Featuring RTX 4090 Laptop GPU and Intel i9-14900HX with 12.5-Inch 4K Display and 175W Mobile GPU

    Self-Taught Modder Creates Fully Transparent Game Boy Color Circuit Board with Stunning Design in Clear Shell

    Self-Taught Modder Creates Fully Transparent Game Boy Color Circuit Board with Stunning Design in Clear Shell

    Hardware Enthusiast Attempts to Run NVMe SSD on Switch 2; Adapter Issues Persist, but Future Possibilities with microSD Express Emulation Remain

    Hardware Enthusiast Attempts to Run NVMe SSD on Switch 2; Adapter Issues Persist, but Future Possibilities with microSD Express Emulation Remain

    U.S. Crackdown Captures Duo Behind Covert GPU Supply to China’s AI Industry

    U.S. Crackdown Captures Duo Behind Covert GPU Supply to China’s AI Industry

    AMD’s Z2 Extreme Surpasses Intel’s Lunar Lake in New Gaming Benchmarks—MSI Claw 8 at 17W Shows Z2E Leading by 8.5%, Slips to 6% at 30W

    AMD’s Z2 Extreme Surpasses Intel’s Lunar Lake in New Gaming Benchmarks—MSI Claw 8 at 17W Shows Z2E Leading by 8.5%, Slips to 6% at 30W

    Nintendo Switch 2 Requires Air Conditioning in Hot Climates: Avoid Playing Above 35°C (95°F) to Prevent Overheating

    Nintendo Switch 2 Requires Air Conditioning in Hot Climates: Avoid Playing Above 35°C (95°F) to Prevent Overheating

No Result
View All Result
Gamera
No Result
View All Result
Home PC Gaming

The ‘WoW Killers’ That Failed to Surpass World of Warcraft

by James O'Donnell
November 24, 2024
in PC Gaming
0 0
0
0
SHARES
1
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The gaming landscape is no stranger to cycles of success and downfall, with countless developers scrambling to create their own versions of the latest major hit. The results? Often, a whole lot of failures. The biggest—and most infamous—instance might just be the mad rush to create the so-called "WoW killer," a massively multiplayer online role-playing game (MMORPG) designed to dethrone Blizzard’s colossal global phenomenon, World of Warcraft, and secure endless riches through monthly subscriptions.

This collective industry misstep became a legendary flop, and I witnessed it unfold firsthand. My journey in games journalism began in 2004, right before WoW launched. My penchant for the game nearly jeopardized my budding career, but instead, it propelled me into a specialization in MMOs—a niche too complex for many writers and editors. I ventured to numerous preview events for hopeful MMOs that PR reps eagerly described as “World of Warcraft, but for soccer,” or “World of Warcraft, but with cars.” In 2008, I joined Eurogamer as the editor of an MMO section—an endeavor driven by the same misguided gold-rush mentality—and it quickly became apparent why these attempts were doomed from the start.

The primary hurdle was that WoW, particularly during its peak from 2004 to 2010, was simply too formidable to overthrow. Moreover, chasing hits is a flawed approach, even under ideal circumstances, and essentially impractical in the social, online game world. Successful games garner fiercely loyal audiences who immerse themselves month after month, rarely seeking an alternative.

These dedicated communities are essentially self-contained, barely swayed by flashy graphics or technical marvels, while constantly updated games have ample opportunities to innovate from within. The strategy of "let’s slap a big name, like Star Wars, on it," also loses its charm here, as more often than not, players prioritize their community ties over blockbuster personas or plots.

Yet, unbelievably, the industry keeps falling into the same trap with online games. Take the spectacular failure of Concord earlier this year, just another in a long line of attempts to topple Overwatch’s supremacy in the hero-shooter domain. So, with a blend of reflection and a touch of schadenfreude, let’s revisit some of the games that tried, and mostly failed, to challenge World of Warcraft, and highlight a few that came close.

The Lord of the Rings Online (2007): This game’s inclusion might be slightly unfair, as the ambition to create a Middle-earth MMO predates Blizzard’s WoW concept. The initial developer, Turbine, envisioned making another niche online project. However, publisher WB Games became overly enthusiastic. The game performed reasonably well but lagged behind WoW’s advancements. Nonetheless, it’s still played today!

Age of Conan (2008): Here comes a cautionary tale of post-WoW arrogance. Developer Funcom ambitiously attempted to inject cutting-edge graphics, violence, sex, and real-time swordplay into an MMO set in Robert E. Howard’s fantasy realm. Publisher Eidos went all in; I recall an absurd press event in Oslo, organized within a 1952 Winter Olympic park transformed into a medieval spectacle with barbarians and feasts. The launch was disastrous, and the game flopped.

Warhammer Online: Age of Reckoning (2008): EA’s ambitious venture appeared sensible, given that the Warhammer license closely mirrors Warcraft. Mythic, its developer, was praised by MMO aficionados for Dark Age of Camelot. The elaborate game, however, was limited, fixated on large-scale player-versus-player combat while WoW excelled in offering a plethora of play styles. Warhammer Online shut down in 2013.

APB: All Points Bulletin (2010): Envisioned as a Grand Theft Auto-like MMO with immense customization capabilities, spearheaded by GTA’s architect David Jones, what could possibly go wrong? Everything! APB boasted plenty of features but forgot the crucial element—gameplay. Realtime Worlds, Jones’ studio, went bankrupt soon after, leading to APB’s closure, and subsequent unsuccessful relaunch.

Rift (2011): The MMO boom wasn’t exclusive to games; companies sprang up, grabbing significant investments with promises of revolutionary tech. Trion Worlds boasted advanced server tech destined to bring MMOs closer to cloud-gaming dreams. Sadly, its flagship fantasy game Rift was lackluster.

Star Wars: The Old Republic (2011): Still smarting from Warhammer Online’s failure, EA embarked once again on a WoW-challenging mission with Star Wars, developed by BioWare, and deep pockets. Despite the overhyped launch, BioWare’s strength lay in solo experiences. Players finished the story and left, not quite the intended outcome. Nevertheless, BioWare rebuilt the game, capitalizing on a successful free-to-play model, maintaining a player base.

Guild Wars 2 (2012): Though deservedly recognized as a superior MMO and perhaps unfairly on this list, Guild Wars 2 introduced refined combat and genre-defining ideas that WoW and others later adopted. Yet, the title couldn’t fulfill publisher NCSoft’s aspirations or catch the ever-adapting WoW.

WildStar (2014): NCSoft attempted to make a Western mark with WildStar, a game resembling World of Warcraft in its vibrant art style, developed by ex-Blizzard folks. While novel, it exemplified trend-focused designs without purpose beyond ousting WoW. Eventually, it closed in 2018.

Now, let’s spotlight the game that nearly dethroned WoW.

Final Fantasy 14 (2013): Steadfast perseverance paid for Square Enix, whose mission transcended challenging Blizzard. Final Fantasy 11 was a pre-WoW success in 2002. Dealing with FF14’s initial failure in 2010, Square Enix, driven by its sense of pride, enlisted producer Naoki Yoshida for a revamp. Yoshida delivered a stellar reboot. Square Enix didn’t waver even when they didn’t match WoW’s numbers, continuing to invest. As Blizzard faced controversies and uninspiring expansions, WoW fans began migrating to FF14, which finally became the worthy contender WoW always needed.

Tags: WorldWarcraftSurpassWoWKillersFailed
Previous Post

Intel’s XeSS Upscaling Technology Now Supported by 200+ Games

Next Post

Ranking the Top 7 Video Game Adaptations

Related Posts

Cult-Classic RPG “Off” Arrives on Steam After 17-Year Wait

Cult-Classic RPG “Off” Arrives on Steam After 17-Year Wait

August 15, 2025
What’s Coming in the Diablo 4 PTR Update 2.4.0?

What’s Coming in the Diablo 4 PTR Update 2.4.0?

August 14, 2025

Smoke grenades dominate the Battlefield 6 beta meta

August 13, 2025

Hellblade 2 Debuts on PS5 with Upgraded Features: Is the Excitement Justified?

August 12, 2025

Sega’s Gaming Division Sees 13% Sales Decline

August 11, 2025

Snag the Complete Batman Arkham Series Plus 12 More Games for Just $12

August 10, 2025
Next Post
Ranking the Top 7 Video Game Adaptations

Ranking the Top 7 Video Game Adaptations

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Today’s Top Deals: Super Mario Party Bash, Nvidia Shield, Apple AirPods 4, and More

    Today’s Top Deals: Super Mario Party Bash, Nvidia Shield, Apple AirPods 4, and More

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • New NES and Game Boy Games Join Nintendo Switch Online

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Civilization VII Featured in This Week’s eShop Highlights

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Free Play Days: Experience Call of Duty: Black Ops 6 (Multiplayer & Zombies), NBA 2K25, and Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mutants Unleashed

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Celebrating 25 Years of The Sims: How an Iconic Series Evolved with Life’s Game

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
Gamera

Gamera brings you breaking gaming updates for PlayStation, Xbox, PC, and Nintendo fans!

Categories

  • Gaming News
  • PlayStation
  • Xbox
  • Nintendo
  • PC Gaming
  • Virtual Reality
  • Consoles
No Result
View All Result

Recent News

  • Call of Duty’s Latest Announcement: A Full Circle Moment That Leaves Me Unsure
  • Cult-Classic RPG “Off” Arrives on Steam After 17-Year Wait
  • Z-A Announces Beneficial Quality of Life Update
  • DMCA
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact us

Copyright © 2025 Gamera - All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Gaming News
  • PlayStation
  • Xbox
  • Nintendo
  • PC Gaming
  • Virtual Reality
  • Consoles

Copyright © 2025 Gamera - All Rights Reserved.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.